Skip to content

IndependentFree guides to UK employment rights. This site is not run by or connected to the government. About this site

Find your way

Need help now?
Acas: 0300 123 1100

Protected conversation: what it means and what to do

Your manager wants an off-the-record chat about you leaving. You do not have to agree, and "protected" is narrower than it sounds. Here is what to say, what to write down, and when to get advice.

  • UK-wide
  • 13 min read

A protected conversation is usually a short meeting where your employer offers you money to leave quietly under a settlement agreement. You can say no, you can ask for time, and you should get advice before you sign anything.

s111A
hides talks in ordinary dismissal claims only
10 days
minimum time Acas says you should get
£30k
tax-free limit for genuine termination payments
6 mths
less a day for most claims from 1 Oct 2026

What just happened to you

It often starts casually. “Can we have a quick off-the-record chat?” Then comes the offer: leave now, take a sum, sign a settlement agreement, and both sides move on.

Employers like this route because it is quick and private. For you, on a care rota or a warehouse night shift or between tables in a busy kitchen, it can feel like an ambush. It is not an order. A protected conversation is an invitation to negotiate your exit. You can decline, pause it, and ask for everything in writing.

If you are on shifts, on probation, or sponsored on a visa, the pressure is real. Refusing does not end your rights. If they then cut your hours, start a sham process or tell you to go, that later conduct can be challenged as being pushed out or as a dismissal with no warning.

Is it really off the record

Only sometimes. There are two different shields, and managers mix them up.

The first is section 111A. It lets an employer and an employee discuss ending the job on agreed terms before any dispute exists, and keeps that discussion inadmissible in an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. That is all it does. It applies in England, Wales and Scotland. It does not apply in Northern Ireland.

The second is the common law without prejudice rule. It is older and wider, but harder to get. It only protects talks where there is already a dispute, or one both sides reasonably contemplate, plus a genuine attempt to settle it. An out of the blue “would you like to leave” with no prior grievance or claim on the table does not qualify.

Two shields compared
QuestionSection 111AWithout prejudice
Needs an existing disputeNoYes
Covers ordinary unfair dismissalYesYes
Covers discrimination and whistleblowingNoYes, if the conditions are met
Covers wages and breach of contractNoYes, if the conditions are met
Who can use itEmployees onlyEmployees, workers and others

If both shields apply, both protect. If neither applies, the tribunal can hear what was said. That is why you should act as if notes might one day be read out, even when the manager says “this stays between us”.

When the tribunal can hear it anyway

Section 111A has an improper behaviour exception. If the employer behaves improperly, the tribunal can admit the conversation so far as it considers just. The tribunal decides, guided by the Acas Code of Practice on settlement agreements.

Acas lists as improper: harassment, bullying and intimidation, physical assault or threats, other criminal behaviour, victimisation, discrimination, and undue pressure. Its examples of undue pressure include refusing reasonable time to consider the offer, telling you before any disciplinary process that you will be dismissed if you refuse, and an employee threatening the employer’s public reputation if the employer does not sign.

Acas also says what is not improper on its own: setting out the reasons for proposing settlement, spelling out the likely alternatives including disciplinary action and possible dismissal, factually saying an offer will not be repeated after dismissal, refusing to agree a reference, refusing to pay for your advice, and asking you to think again after you first said no.

What “protected” does not cover

This is where workers lose most. Section 111A blocks the talk only in ordinary unfair dismissal claims. It does not block it in:

Discrimination under the Equality Act 2010. Whistleblowing detriment and dismissal. Since 6 April 2026, disclosing sexual harassment counts as whistleblowing. Automatic unfair dismissal, such as dismissal for pregnancy, maternity, asserting minimum wage or trade union activity. Wrongful dismissal and breach of contract. Unlawful deduction of wages and holiday pay.

In those claims the offer itself can be evidence. An exit offer pitched because you are disabled, pregnant, Black, older or on maternity leave can itself be discrimination. An offer that follows your complaint about unpaid wages or short measured shifts can support victimisation or detriment claims. If you raised a grievance and met a disciplinary threat, keep both paper trails separate and dated.

How long they must give you

Acas says you should get at least 10 calendar days to consider a written settlement offer and get independent advice. It is guidance, not a hard right to exactly 10 days, but tribunals treat a rush as evidence of undue pressure. Acas gives allowing only a weekend as an example of improper pressure.

Reasonableness depends on the facts. Complex terms, ill health, night shifts or a need to see a solicitor or union officer all point to longer. If they set 48 hours, reply in writing: “I need the Acas 10 calendar days to take advice.” Keep the message.

In Northern Ireland s111A does not apply and the 10 day guidance is not NI law. There only without prejudice talks, which need an existing dispute, can keep the discussion hidden. If you work in Northern Ireland, read our guide to employment law in Northern Ireland and get local advice before treating anything as off record.

If you say yes: what makes it binding

A verbal yes settles nothing. To waive statutory employment claims the deal must be a settlement agreement that meets section 203 of the Employment Rights Act 1996. All of these must hold: it is in writing, it relates to the particular complaint, you received advice from a relevant independent adviser covered by insurance and unconnected with the employer, the agreement names the adviser, and it states that the section 203 conditions are met.

The adviser is usually a solicitor or a certified union officer. Good employers pay a contribution toward that advice, but they do not have to. If the contribution is low, ask for more. Do not sign until the adviser has walked through every waiver.

Check four clauses with the adviser. The money breakdown. The reference: agreed wording attached to the agreement is far stronger than “a reference will be provided”. Confidentiality and non disclosure terms: what you cannot say, to whom, and the carve outs for whistleblowing, reporting crime and talking to regulators. And post termination restrictions: most shop floor, care and warehouse staff should not accept wide non compete terms to get an exit payment.

Signing can affect benefits. A payment in lieu of wages can affect Universal Credit in the assessment period in which it is received. If you resign by agreement you can face questions about voluntary leaving for Jobseeker’s Allowance. Speak to Citizens Advice before you agree a leaving date and payment split if you claim or may claim.

Money and tax: what the sum is made of

Do not invent a target from internet anecdotes. Pull the offer apart into parts. Notice pay owed under contract or statute. Accrued but untaken holiday. Any statutory redundancy pay if you have two years or more. Arrears of wages, sick pay or holiday pay. Then the extra, often called ex gratia or compensation for loss of office.

Example: Amara’s offer

Amara is a care assistant on £12.71 an hour, the National Living Wage from 1 April 2026, working 37.5 hours a week. That is about £476.63 a week, about £2,065.38 a month gross. She is offered 4 weeks notice plus £2,000 ex gratia. Notice is roughly £1,906.50 and is taxed as wages through payroll. The £2,000 sits on top. Total headline about £3,906.50, but only the £2,000 can fall inside the £30,000 tax-free rule. Her adviser checks payslips for travel time and sleep-in arrears before she accepts, because signing would waive those too.

Tax works like this. The first £30,000 of a genuine termination payment is free of income tax. Post-employment notice pay, the notice slice of the payment, is fully taxable as earnings since 6 April 2018. Employers pay Class 1A National Insurance on amounts above £30,000. Statutory redundancy pay counts inside the £30,000 exemption.

Larger sums show the edge clearly. Take £40,000 labelled wholly as compensation for loss of office, with no notice owed. The first £30,000 is tax free. The other £10,000 is taxed as income. At 20 percent basic rate that slice nets £8,000, so £38,000 before any other adjustments. Scotland has different rates, and marginal rates change the result, so make the adviser confirm the net figure in writing.

Cross-check redundancy if you qualify. From 6 April 2026 weekly pay for the statutory formula is capped at £751. Amara, aged 35 with five years, on £476.63 actual pay, would get 5 x 1.0 x £476.63 = £2,383.15. If your offer is below notice plus holiday plus any redundancy and arrears, it is not a premium. It is a shortfall. Our redundancy pay guide shows the age bands.

Your contract status and where you live

Only employees can claim ordinary unfair dismissal, so only employees get s111A protection as claimants. Workers, including many zero-hours, bank and casual staff, keep discrimination, whistleblowing detriment, wages and holiday claims, but s111A does not shield them. Without prejudice can still help if there is a genuine existing dispute.

Agency workers are usually workers, sometimes employees of the agency, and have no unfair dismissal claim against the hirer. Genuinely self-employed contractors sit outside these rules entirely. If you were told you are self-employed but work set shifts under close control, check status before signing anything that calls you self-employed. Our false self-employment guide shows the tests.

Migrants on tied visas have the same employment rights on paper. The pressure point is fear about sponsorship, references and shifts, not weaker law. Do not let a manager link your visa to the signature. Get advice from your union and a regulated immigration adviser alongside the employment advice.

  1. Section 111A begins

    Pre-termination negotiations become inadmissible in ordinary unfair dismissal claims in England, Wales and Scotland.

  2. Notice pay taxed

    Post-employment notice pay becomes fully taxable as earnings. The £30,000 exemption continues for genuine termination payments.

  3. Fair Work Agency established

    The Fair Work Agency is established. It enforces the minimum wage, regulates employment agencies, and licenses labour suppliers in agriculture and food.

  4. Six-month qualifying period scheduled

    Employees are scheduled to gain ordinary unfair dismissal rights after six months instead of two years. The two-year rule applies until then.

What to do in the next 48 hours

  1. Write it down tonight. Date, time, room, exact words, who else heard, what sum and deadline were mentioned. Email the notes to yourself. Contemporaneous notes carry weight.
  2. Ask for it in writing. The draft agreement, the money breakdown, the leaving date, the reference wording, and confirmation of the 10 calendar days. If they refuse, note the refusal.
  3. Get advice fast. Contact your union rep or join one now: USDAW for retail, UNISON or GMB for care and NHS support, Unite Hospitality for kitchens bars and hotels, IWGB for riders and couriers. Or call Acas and your local Citizens Advice or law centre. Do not pay a solicitor before asking about the employer contribution.
  4. Do not resign yet. Resigning before advice can cut sick pay, notice and benefit options. Stay professional, keep shifts unless sick, and raise any discrimination or pay complaint separately in writing if it applies.
  5. Protect deadlines. Notify Acas about early conciliation before the tribunal clock runs out. For events from 1 October 2026 that is usually six months less a day, for earlier events three months less a day, counted from termination or from the act complained of in discrimination and detriment cases. For Scottish tribunal breach-of-contract claims, if your employment ended before 9 November 2026, the limit is still three months less a day; if it ended on or after that date, the six-month limit applies. Our guide to tribunal time limits and how to claim unfair dismissal sets out the clock. Missing it usually ends the claim.

Questions people ask

Do I have to go to the meeting?

No. You can decline or ask to rearrange with advice and support. Saying no is allowed, but punishing you for it is not automatically unlawful. Cuts to hours, a sudden performance case or dismissal after refusal may itself be unlawful. Keep rotas, messages and payslips.

Is 10 days a legal right?

It is Acas guidance on what is reasonable, not a statute giving exactly 10 days. In practice tribunals treat much shorter deadlines as pressure. Ask in writing for at least 10 calendar days and for time to see an independent adviser.

Do I need a solicitor and who pays?

You need an independent adviser for the agreement to be binding: a qualified lawyer or certified union officer with insurance. Many employers contribute to the fee. If their contribution does not cover full advice on all your claims, ask them to increase it before you sign.

I am pregnant, disabled, or the only migrant worker picked. Does “protected” still cover them?

No. If the reason for picking you is a protected characteristic, or retaliation for whistleblowing or asserting rights such as minimum wage, the talk can be shown to a tribunal in those claims. Get advice urgently and set out the facts in writing. Read our guides to pregnancy discrimination and whistleblowing protection.

Will the payment be taxed?

Notice pay and holiday pay are taxed as wages. Genuine compensation for loss of office gets the first £30,000 free of income tax, with tax due above that. Make the draft state which part is which, and get the net figure confirmed for your tax band.

What if I refuse and they sack me?

Do not delay. Note the dismissal date, ask for written reasons, contact Acas about early conciliation, and read our early conciliation guide plus how to claim unfair dismissal. For events from 1 October 2026 the deadline is usually six months less a day from termination. For Scottish tribunal breach-of-contract claims, if your employment ended before 9 November 2026, the limit is still three months less a day; if it ended on or after that date, the six-month limit applies. Start the clock from day one.

Sources

  1. Employment Rights Act 1996, section 111A, legislation.gov.uk
  2. Acas Code of Practice on settlement agreements, Acas
  3. Confidentiality and without prejudice in settlement agreements, Acas
  4. Employment Rights Act 1996, section 203, legislation.gov.uk
  5. Employment Rights Act 2025, section 25, legislation.gov.uk
  6. Employment Rights Act 2025 update, Acas
  7. Treatment of termination payments, GOV.UK
  8. Employment Income Manual EIM13500, HMRC
  9. Employment Income Manual EIM13876 on post-employment notice pay, HMRC
  10. National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates, GOV.UK
  11. Employment tribunal time limits, Acas
  12. Explaining your redundancy payments, GOV.UK
  13. National Minimum Wage enforcement and compliance report 2024 to 2025, Department for Business and Trade
  14. Tribunal Statistics Quarterly April to June 2026, Ministry of Justice
  15. Exploitative zero-hours contracts are endemic, TUC, August 2026

More in Discipline & termination

All guides in this topic